pricey but does the job
January 6, 2009
Finally gave up trying to make my other lids work for my 12" All-Clad fry pan. Had debated about getting this cover a while back but found it too pricey. It's still too pricey, but it fits, its sturdy and lovely, too.
Loose, sloppy fit. I am not happy with the purchase...
December 19, 2008
I recently purchased an All Clad 12 inch skillet and lid. My pan and lid have approximately 1/8 to 1/4 inch of play between the edges of the skillet and lid. I would expect this from a cheap set of pots and pans, but not from All Clad. A few of the other reviewers have also mentioned issues regarding the fit.
I have an 8 inch All Clad skillet and lid and those two fit perfectly. It appears there may be a production/quality problem with the 12 inch lid. I am not happy with the purchase.
Fry pan lid
July 23, 2008
Looks great and serves the purpose with the pan. I am very curious as to why the package says made in China as I thought All Clad was made in Pennsylvania USA?
sloppy fit
(2 of 2 Found this Helpful)
June 2, 2008
As another reviewer pointed out, this lid doesn't seal as well as it should. I suppose the 5-star reviews received a slightly different product.
In comparison, the All-Clad lids for my 10.5 inch frying pan an 1-quart sauce pan fit perfectly.
I gave it only 2 stars because of the fit was not what I expect for a $47 lid.
Pricey Lid
May 31, 2008
I purchased this lid for a 12" Calphalon skillet and it fits. All-Clad is expensive but it ia also high quality cookware. I am very pleased but it would be nice if it was not so expensive. Great looking and no worries about oven use.
